"Really for a story told in the first person by a precocious child whose greatest joy is to be tucked into bed and kissed by is mommy... this is about as good as it gets. The narrator goes on to describe myriad things that he could not have possibly been privy to, which is never explained despite the 600+ pages of room to explain such a thing. The writing is so terribly pedantic and rambling, that it is like a simile, a round and happy simile with a moustache and the unforgettable smell of an old barber shop, that has perhaps booked an airline ticket to some favourite place, only to learn that during the flight that it is hijacked by a giant and menacing metaphor and ummm... where was I? Oh yes, reviewing Proust. If you don't like me and you are pretty sure that I don't like you, please read this book... at least twice."
"Read all of Part 1. I consider this an achievement when reading the longest, most boring, whiny text in the history of mankind ... This is a terrible book that should only be read as some kind of mental BDSM play."
"Proust is sedentary. Dialog is mostly the talk at grand dinners. Action usually consists of going for a walk. These are hardly stock items for books written in the last century, which, if nothing else, features movement, dialog essential to that movement, and action based on incident.
I think the movies – or at least film – color the way novels are written in the modern world. The lengthy descriptions we find in Proust are not needed any more. I’ve never been to Paris, but I know what Paris looks like. And, as was often the case in Swan’s Way, I want the characters to do something. Move."
"I read it because I did a seminar on memory in literature at uni 7 years ago. Maybe if I read it back then, I might have been a bit more enthusiastic. As it is, I found the sentences way too long. And overall, as with 'Swann's Love' which I am currently abandoning, I think the narrator take a long time to say rather little.
I'm focused on content and...well...I understand that it is about regression or memory and remembering and so forth but, I guess I expected ..more for lack of a better word.
At least it had some homosexual content (which surprised me positively). But well...it's rather exhausting I think to read one sentence that runs over half the page."
Showing posts with label proust. Show all posts
Showing posts with label proust. Show all posts
Sunday, July 8, 2012
Tuesday, January 17, 2012
Marcel Proust - In Search of Lost Time II
"Omg, I hated reading this. I could tell you why, like a real book review, but I can't even deal. I'm just glad I'm finally done. Freedom!!!!
Book dish: madeleine."
"i hate marcel proust... i dont know how much proust sucks in english but in french he sucks a _______ (insert nasty adjective and noun here).... i hate him and my french teacher for making me read over 100 pages of his rambling thoughts in one week... i mean no one wants to read my ADD thoughts for something like five volumes with each being a thousand pages long, so why would we want to read theirs...."
"Absolutely dreadful book cannot think of anything good to say about it. Awkward disjointed style, surprised there are not three pages devoted to paint drying. One feels no connection with the characters other than possibly distaste. Four or so pages devoted to a ten year old boy machinating on whether he is going to get a good night kiss from Mama. That's about as exciting as it gets."
"Nobody reads the book/ takes the assignment seriously because really, it is a pointless waste of time. Also, Proust was a whiney SOB"
"Proust sucks the big one. In search of lost time is the biggest waste of time I've ever put myself through."
"seriously, dude, fuck proust."
"Meh. Proust sucks as well.
:)
Kurt Vonnegut, John Fante and Donald Barthelme. One doesn't need more than that."
"Proust sucks dick. french people suck dick in general. only good thing to come out of france be like m83 and dior."
"Proust sucks, and so does Dtocheimsky, or however you spell it."
Book dish: madeleine."
"i hate marcel proust... i dont know how much proust sucks in english but in french he sucks a _______ (insert nasty adjective and noun here).... i hate him and my french teacher for making me read over 100 pages of his rambling thoughts in one week... i mean no one wants to read my ADD thoughts for something like five volumes with each being a thousand pages long, so why would we want to read theirs...."
"Absolutely dreadful book cannot think of anything good to say about it. Awkward disjointed style, surprised there are not three pages devoted to paint drying. One feels no connection with the characters other than possibly distaste. Four or so pages devoted to a ten year old boy machinating on whether he is going to get a good night kiss from Mama. That's about as exciting as it gets."
"Nobody reads the book/ takes the assignment seriously because really, it is a pointless waste of time. Also, Proust was a whiney SOB"
"Proust sucks the big one. In search of lost time is the biggest waste of time I've ever put myself through."
"seriously, dude, fuck proust."
"Meh. Proust sucks as well.
:)
Kurt Vonnegut, John Fante and Donald Barthelme. One doesn't need more than that."
"Proust sucks dick. french people suck dick in general. only good thing to come out of france be like m83 and dior."
"Proust sucks, and so does Dtocheimsky, or however you spell it."
Wednesday, February 9, 2011
Marcel Proust - In Search of Lost Time
"There's no way he'd make a decent TV listings writer. I soon got into the habit of reading the first three words of a sentence, and then judging whether to pursue the rest of it. It worked quite well as a technique in terms of getting me through the book."
"The main problem with Proust (and his admirers) is that they are convinced that the French aristocracy, with all their trivial concerns and all their trivial conversations, were actually interesting. In reality, they were very dull and conventional people. One of Proust's friends actually said that to him, but Proust was too status-struck to listen.
The only character in the books I liked was Charles Morel"
"such unnecessary language..."
"A lot of peeps be saying that Proust and not Joyce is the best writer ever (or of the 20th century, which is the same thing really) but judging from this first volume Proust is merely the culmination of the literary styles before him while Joyce moves beyond those and off into other realms entirely. Joyce is also a more proletariat, less romantic writer."
"Proust may have ushered in a Modernist era of psychological literature, may have provided a model of inspiration for Virginia Woolf to turn into stream-of-consciousness prose, and may have made inroads towards turning out generations of homosexual authors, and yet it's impossible to forget that he was a landed gentleman who could afford to shut himself up in his house and write uninterrupted for hour after hour, day after day, year after year."
"I really now know that the style of Marcel Proust is not the one I like. And I tried. This is the second book I tried to read. And still no interesting reading. I must admit that I do not like at all Proust. His twisted phrases, plain books, descriptive scenes of french high class society from the begining of 20th centuryy does not fit me."
"I just can't devour this man."
"Friends! We write in hopes of being read, and common sense ought to tell us that SOLID BLOCKS OF UNBROKEN TEXT will more often than not go unread because they are just too hard on the eyes and almost as difficult to read as words would be if they too were strung together without breaks.
Quite apart from any consideration of M. Proust, has it never occurred to his reviewers that phalanx-like SOLID BLOCKS OF UNBROKEN TEXT are too formidable in aspect and, rather than attracting potential readers, will instead serve to repel them?"
I UNDERSTAND MOST SCHOLARS OF PROUST REFER TO THESE AS "PARAGRAPHS". TO FINISH ON A HIGH NOTE FOR ONCE:
"I decided to undertake the cycle for two reasons: 1) because it's widely considered to be the greatest modern novel of all time ... 2) to discover the meaning of life. After reading over 4,300 pages, I would say I accomplished both goals."
"The main problem with Proust (and his admirers) is that they are convinced that the French aristocracy, with all their trivial concerns and all their trivial conversations, were actually interesting. In reality, they were very dull and conventional people. One of Proust's friends actually said that to him, but Proust was too status-struck to listen.
The only character in the books I liked was Charles Morel"
"such unnecessary language..."
"A lot of peeps be saying that Proust and not Joyce is the best writer ever (or of the 20th century, which is the same thing really) but judging from this first volume Proust is merely the culmination of the literary styles before him while Joyce moves beyond those and off into other realms entirely. Joyce is also a more proletariat, less romantic writer."
"Proust may have ushered in a Modernist era of psychological literature, may have provided a model of inspiration for Virginia Woolf to turn into stream-of-consciousness prose, and may have made inroads towards turning out generations of homosexual authors, and yet it's impossible to forget that he was a landed gentleman who could afford to shut himself up in his house and write uninterrupted for hour after hour, day after day, year after year."
"I really now know that the style of Marcel Proust is not the one I like. And I tried. This is the second book I tried to read. And still no interesting reading. I must admit that I do not like at all Proust. His twisted phrases, plain books, descriptive scenes of french high class society from the begining of 20th centuryy does not fit me."
"I just can't devour this man."
"Friends! We write in hopes of being read, and common sense ought to tell us that SOLID BLOCKS OF UNBROKEN TEXT will more often than not go unread because they are just too hard on the eyes and almost as difficult to read as words would be if they too were strung together without breaks.
Quite apart from any consideration of M. Proust, has it never occurred to his reviewers that phalanx-like SOLID BLOCKS OF UNBROKEN TEXT are too formidable in aspect and, rather than attracting potential readers, will instead serve to repel them?"
I UNDERSTAND MOST SCHOLARS OF PROUST REFER TO THESE AS "PARAGRAPHS". TO FINISH ON A HIGH NOTE FOR ONCE:
"I decided to undertake the cycle for two reasons: 1) because it's widely considered to be the greatest modern novel of all time ... 2) to discover the meaning of life. After reading over 4,300 pages, I would say I accomplished both goals."
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)